Can Providence Survive More Apartments in Superman Building?
Friday, April 11, 2014
“The residential units proposed in the Superman Building, when completed and with the extra charges added to the rent or sale of the unit, will not be affordable to most Rhode Islanders. Most of these units will remain empty for years,” said Dr. Edward M. Mazze, Distinguished Professor of Business Administration at The University of Rhode Island.
“The city should not fund housing projects by providing special deals. Government officials should not be dazzled by slick presentations, pro-forma financial statements, models of the construction project and promises of the future. If the project makes economic sense, private investors will put in their money because of the returns they will receive. Providence can then collect the taxes it needs to support city programs. If the project makes no economic sense, the builder will go to the government for funding or relief and Providence taxpayers will get hurt.”
Development spokesperson Bill Fischer said the project will work because the city needs a new renaissance. He believes it takes state and municipal support to attract private developers to a city where the downtown market is starving for residential rental units.
“Every market study – not just ours, but every study you can find anywhere – will demonstrate that occupancy rates in the greater downtown area are all in the 90 percentile. The 903. The Renaissance. People want to live in walk able, livable cities. Millenials want to live in walk able, livable cities. They do not want to move to the suburbs. We have to start thinking long term about this city and this state,” Fischer said.
Fischer believes the last thing the city needs is more office space. This makes the Superman building project interesting to Thomas Sweeney, of Sweeney Real Estate and Appraisal, who believes office space will most likely be developed in the I-195/Link redevelopment area or on the unimproved lots in Capital Center.
“Amica left the city in the late 1980s, early 1990s. While Bank of America moved out of 111 Westminster, they moved into both 100 West and One Financial, retaining a significant number of jobs in the Financial District,” Sweeney said.
“I think there needs to be a balance between the residential and office uses. The fact that 111 really is no longer viable as office space makes the proposed conversion an interesting possibility. I think the City and State should look at all options to encourage development in order to create both places to live and jobs, which will increase the demand for office space.”
The new proposal from the building’s owner, High Rock Development, calls for tens of millions in Federal Tax Credits and $39 million in State dollars to subsidize the project. High Rock would not receive any money until the building renovation is completed with a certificate of occupancy issued. High Rock will purchase a private completion bond in an amount sufficient to guarantee completion of the project - thus ensuring all economic and employment benefits to the State of Rhode Island are realized in the event that the owner is unable to complete the project.
Gary Sasse, Founding Director of the Hassenfeld Institute for Public Leadership at Bryant University and former Executive Director Rhode Island Public Expenditure, said the Superman Building currently represents a “lose-lose” problem both for the owner and the Cit.
“Providing preferential tax treatment and other public incentives for a unprofitable undertaking would not be a sound investment that results in a sustainable project. For the Superman Building redevelopment to be a win, strong, visionary and fiscally conservative leadership will be needed to turn the building from chicken manure into chicken salad,” Sasse said.
For the taxpayers to be asked to subsidized redevelopment of the building, Sasse said Superman due diligence by the General Assembly and City Administration should prove the following beyond any reasonable doubt;
1. The business plan demonstrates there is a robust market for the contemplated use of the Superman Building.
2. The business plan identifies when the venture will result in a return on investment.
3. The owners provide collateral to secure any public expenditure or subsidy.
4. The owners underwrite a realistic share of Kennedy Plaza redevelopment efforts. (In their proposal, High Rock shall contribute $50,000.00 annually into the fund for a period of ten years – $500,000 total – to help fund organizations such as the Downtown Providence Parks Conservancy for the maintenance, enhancement and programming of Kennedy Plaza.)
5. The property tax stabilization be for a defined period with programed reduction over the life of the stabilization agreement.
6. The City show how the investment in the Superman Building fits into an overall downtown revival strategy.
7. Funds are identified to build an appropriate public infrastructure as well parking.
Misinformation coupled with a public already burned by the 38 Studios failure may be the Kryptonite stuck inside this project’s success. Fischer was quick to address this with what he called three important facts.
“These are not condos. This downtown market is starving for residential rental units. The last thing Providence needs right now is more office space,” he said.
As for the perceived hesitance to support a millionaire’s project with taxpayers’ money, Fischer said projects of this size are nearly always completed this way. But they need vision. If the numbers are right, if 1000 construction jobs can start next year with this project, Fischer said people need to understand that big projects like the Superman Building and South Street Station can kick start an economy.
“There has not been a major project in this city and throughout Rhode Island that has not received state and city support. American Locomotive, The Arcade, The Foundry. And, by the way, breaking news: There’s $54 million in old historic tax credits sitting over at South Street. The Masonic temple received $31 million in state and federal historic tax credits,” he said.
“The problem we have, and it’s a real problem, is that construction costs in Providence and Boston are quite similar. The problem is the rents that Boston gets are about 40 percent higher. That is a real development challenge.”
If they build it, will they come?
Mazze said there are many homegrown hurdles for projects such as the Superman Building to leap.
“During the next five years, the growth in good paying jobs in Rhode Island will be for jobs located outside of Providence. The real need for housing in Providence is for families needing affordable housing and students attending colleges in the city. This market, unless subsidized by tax credits or other government support, is not as profitable for builders as is constructing higher priced residential units,” Mazze said.
“Even though Providence tries to portray itself as a great place to live, many of the amenities that city dwellers want do not exist. Residential building projects with more than ten units in Providence are extremely risky.”
Mayoral candidates weigh in
"The Superman Building has been an iconic structure in the city for many years, and we need to come together and make a responsible, transparent plan to make it productive again. We have many remarkable examples of how city leaders have worked together to preserve historic architecture, create jobs and revitalize downtown and 111 Westminster shouldn't be any different, said City Council President and Mayoral candidate Michael Solomon.
“The city and the state need to work together to ensure that taxpayers are protected and that we all do our best to kick start the economy. In our creative capital full of young people, artists and entrepreneurs, there is a need for more affordable apartment living. Ensuring that we have adequate affordable housing options and supporting businesses are not mutually exclusive; our downtown businesses, both new and existing, need affordable and available housing for their workforce."
Lone GOP Mayoral Candidate Dan Harrop said the project is another example of the “give-aways” that are sinking the city.
“Part of the reason we are in trouble in Providence – $600 million deficit in the pension fund, a billion deficit in the benefits fund, a billion in deferred maintenance – is the ‘give-aways’ Democratic politicians in the Mayor's office and city council have been giving for decades. At best, the city should take an ownership position in lieu of taxes in projects that are essential to the city,” Harrop said.
“By taking an ownership position we at least have the opportunity of gaining back our investment (lost taxes) at some point in the future. Think of how this would have made a difference today if we did this 30 years ago. If the Superman Building is such a great economic deal, it should be able to find public money on its own. In general, though, I am not in favor of politicians picking favorites to support financially. They tend to be very bad at it, cannot separate out political factors and just look at business factors, and the 38 Studios debacle or the impending Biltmore debacle or the scandal of the Providence Economic Development Partnership only emphasizes this.”
Brett Smiley believes the new economy comes with workers who want to be centrally located to everything in their lives.
“Workers don’t want to travel far from home for business or for leisure. In order to be competitive, Providence does need more affordable, residential space Downtown, but we also must find the appropriate balance between housing, employment and nightlife. When looking at a new development Downtown, and especially one that may require a public subsidy, it's essential that the project produce a public good that warrants the public investment."
Jorge Elorza said he believes the Superman Building is iconic and deserves saving, but not at the expense of more important city issues.
"The Superman Building is an iconic piece of our City’s skyline, and we should work to restore it. The prospect of rebirth as residential or mixed-use space is exciting, and it will breathe even more life into our city center. With that said, any decisions we make about subsidies for development need to be balanced with investments in our neighborhoods, rehabilitation of our schools, fixing potholes, bringing abandoned properties back into the housing market, and supporting middle-class businesses in our neighborhoods."
Lorne Adrain spoke of a world where people are rediscovering urban centers.
"Throughout the world, people are moving back to cities, from young professionals to retirees. We should encourage people to invest in downtown Providence living by offering them a vibrant and attractive environment. Providence has been named one of the best American cities to live in. The Arcade and Providence G showcase Providence's potential, and we should help that potential come alive: an entrepreneurial economy that creates more jobs in our city will also create demand for housing downtown. The Superman building can be an important part of inspiring and enabling this kind of growth. This kind of progress is important and we must be creative in facilitating it without putting taxpayers on the hook.”
Related Slideshow: 7 Strategies for Rhode Island Economic Development in 2014
What will it take to move the Rhode Island economy forward in 2014? GoLocal talked with elected officials, candidates, and leaders for their economic development plans in the coming year.
Below are key elements of the economic priorities for Governor Lincoln Chafee, Speaker of the House Gordon Fox, Senate President M. Teresa Paiva-Weed, House Minority Leader Brian Newberry, gubernatorial hopefuls General Treasurer Gina Raimondo and Ken Block, and RI Center for Freedom and Prosperity's Mike Stenhouse.
Governor Lincoln Chafee
Speaker Gordon Fox
"Among the many pieces of legislation the House will address will be issues of higher education affordability, expanding apprenticeship opportunities, and offering help to our manufacturers. We will also look closely at our tax structure to make sure we are competitive with our neighboring states, including the corporate tax and the estate tax, and I will carefully review the recommendations of the commission studying our sales tax.”
Senate Pres. Paiva-Weed
Greg Pare, spokesperson for the Senate President, said that the Senate is planning to issue recommendations soon on workforce development initiatives to address the skills gap among Rhode Island job seekers.
"An example of a proposal anticipated in that report is the elimination of state’s Indirect Cost Recovery on the Job Development Fund, which is about $1.2 million this year. Those funds would be directed towards job training and skills development programs to provide immediate impact and help workers gain the skills necessary to succeed in today’s economy."
Gen. Treasurer Raimondo
"To grow our economy, we need to make Rhode Island a leader in manufacturing again. Great things can happen at the intersection of government, higher education, and the private sector. Rhode Island is lucky to have thriving institutions in each of these three sectors, and we need to foster collaboration among them to find solutions to our challenges, and spark our economy.
By promoting partnerships in high-growth areas, [Rhode Island Innovation Institute] will help grow our manufacturing base, and create new, high-quality jobs."
"First, we need to fix Rhode Island’s broken Unemployment Insurance program. The state’s Unemployment Insurance tax, paid by employers, is ranked worst in the country by the Tax Foundation. It is one of the factors that makes Rhode Island an uncompetitive place to do business. Also, it is inherently unfair that a large group of businesses are effectively subsidizing the payrolls of a small group of businesses who misuse the system. There is a simple change to state law that can fix this problem."
"Rhode Island’s temporary disability tax (TDI) is broken, and places an unnecessarily high tax burden on Rhode Islanders. This tax, paid for by employees, will be reduced by changing the way we manage the program. As Governor, I will substantially reduce the cost of purchasing this insurance by requiring that Rhode Island’s program adhere to national norms."
"To best encourage new job creation, I propose the following tax incentive: exempt from future capital gains taxes any new investments in Rhode Island-based businesses. This change would create a powerful incentive for investors who are deciding where to locate a new business, or where they relocate an existing one. This proposal has the potential change the economic playing field for Rhode Island."
Minority Leader Newberry
“It would be overly ambitious to set being #1 as a goal right now, but we think 25, the middle of the pack, is a reasonable goal to set, one we think we should pursue, and one we can achieve,” said Newberry. "One of the initiatives is a requirement that every bill receive a fiscal evaluation before it can be heard by committee, better insuring that legislators know the real cost of the legislation they are acting on."
"Another proposal would exempt social security income from RI state income tax, making Rhode Island more tax-friendly for our seniors and keeping them here rather than migrating to more tax-friendly states."
“Strong action is way overdue here. Nearly 60% of Rhode Islanders now believe that the state is headed in the wrong direction. We think they’re right, and our central goal is to get it turned around."
- John Hazen White’s Lookout: Superman Lights Will Shine Again
- PODCAST: Will Superman Building Proposal Stand Chance for Success?
- Will New Superman Building Proposal Stand Chance for Success?
- LISTEN: Superman Building Players + Who’s Hot and Who’s Not
- Providence “Superman Building” Closes—GOP as New Superman
- LISTEN: Superman Deal Similar to 38Studios?
- Rep O’Neill Criticizes Fox & Superman Plan - Similar to 38 Studios
- Lisa Blais: No Public-Private Deals For Superman Building
- Russell Moore: Superman Is Not Curt Schilling
- NEW: Block Says Superman Building Has All the Makings of 38 Studios
- Superman Building Plans Heat Up: Who Are the Players?
- NEW: Superman Building Owner Seeking $70-$75M for Renovations
- The Scoop: Superman Building Spokesman Talking for Pell
- Donna Perry: Superman Building Tax Credit Not So Super
- New Proposal: Ten of Millions of Taxpayer Funds for Superman Bldg
- The Superman Building: Downtown’s Ticking Time Bomb
- Guest MINDSETTER™ Steve Durkee: Why Providence Needs Superman
- PODCAST: Providence Superman Building
- Waiting for Superman - The Rhode Island Premiere